Tired of losing countless warlocks and demons to the powerful Charmed Ones, an Infernal Council sends a fast-talking genie to destroy the Power of Three by granting each sister a wish. Prue's wish for the thrill of first love turns her into a rebellious 17-year-old; Phoebe's wish for an active power gives her the ability to fly; while Piper's wish that Dan get over her turns him into an old man.
original airdate--May 18,2000 rating--4.5 million
Songs: Charmed Theme song--How Soon is Now by Love Spit Love
Book of Shadows: Dragon Warlock
Spell: Warlock Spell
Smoke-Whirling: A type of Teleportation used by the Genie.
Shrinking: Used by the Genie to shrink himself into the bottle.
Projection: Used by the Genie to grant the Charmed Ones' wishes.
Flight: Used by Phoebe to inadvertedly float after unintentionally stealing the power from the Dragon Warlock, to carry the frozen Warlock out of the Manor, to look Prue over an area and used by the Dragon Warlock to attempt to escape from a Power of Three spell.
Premonition: Used by Phoebe to see where the Genie's bottle is.
Fire Breathing: Used by the Dragon Warlock to attack the Charmed Ones.
Molecular Immobilization: Used by Piper to freeze the interior of the Café Le Blue.
Healing: Used by Leo (unsuccessfully) to heal a dying, teenaged Prue.
Orbing: A type of Teleportation used by Leo.
Telekinesis: Used by Prue to shut the Manor door.
Magical Beings: Genie / Dragon Warlock / The Infernal Council
Goofs: At the end of the "Be Careful What You Witch For" when Prue magically closes the door, there is a wall and staircase behind her, yet the front door of the Manor has been repeatedly shown to open on a long hallway.
Trivia: The title is based upon the warning to be wary of magical gifts, "Be careful what you wish for".